Gas vs Electric Water Heater Operating Cost Comparison 2026
Short Answer: A heat pump water heater usually has the lowest operating cost, electric resistance is usually the most expensive, and natural gas can still be competitive where gas prices are low. The right choice depends on local electricity rates, gas or propane prices, household hot-water use, venting, available space, and rebate rules.
Many homeowners compare purchase price and miss the operating-cost gap. A cheap electric resistance tank can cost far more over ten years than a higher-priced heat pump water heater. A gas tankless unit can save space and deliver long showers, but its installation cost, venting, and cold-climate flow rate need to be part of the comparison.
| Water heater type | Typical operating-cost position | Best fit | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Electric resistance tank | Highest in many markets | Low-use cabins or low upfront budget | High annual electricity cost |
| Natural gas tank | Moderate where gas is cheap | Existing gas homes with simple venting | Combustion venting and future gas-price risk |
| Gas tankless | Moderate fuel use, high install cost | Large households needing long hot-water draws | Gas-line and venting upgrades |
| Propane tank | Often expensive | Rural homes without better options | Volatile fuel delivery cost |
| Heat pump water heater | Usually lowest operating cost | Basements, garages, utility rooms with enough air volume | Space, condensate drain, noise, and recovery rate |
Water-heating share varies with climate, occupancy, fuel, equipment, fixtures, and other household loads. That is why this page uses a repeatable local-cost method instead of one national bill estimate.
The comparison covers electric resistance, natural-gas and propane storage, gas tankless, and heat pump water heaters. Each option must be tested against the same delivered hot-water load and installed boundary.
The Direct Answer: Cost per Unit of Delivered Hot Water
Comparing a price per kWh with a price per gallon of propane tells you nothing until both are converted to the same thing: the cost of one million BTU (MMBTU) of heat actually delivered into the water, after the equipment's efficiency. The formula is the same for every fuel:
Cost per MMBTU delivered = (price per billing unit x billing units in one MMBTU) / UEF
Priced at recent U.S. residential averages from the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA), the ranking looks like this. Electricity uses the EIA Form EIA-861 final 2025 U.S. residential average of 17.23 cents per kWh. Propane uses the EIA weekly residential average of $2.598 per gallon for the week ending October 5, 2026, the first reading of the 2026-27 heating season. Natural gas uses a labeled hypothetical $1.50 per therm, because residential gas prices vary more by utility than the other two fuels; replace it with the marginal rate on your own bill.
| Option | Fuel price used | UEF used | Cost per MMBTU delivered |
|---|---|---|---|
| Heat pump water heater | $0.1723 per kWh | 3.50 | $14.43 |
| Gas tankless (condensing) | $1.50 per therm (hypothetical) | 0.90 | $16.67 |
| Natural gas tank | $1.50 per therm (hypothetical) | 0.60 | $25.00 |
| Propane tankless (condensing) | $2.598 per gallon | 0.90 | $31.56 |
| Propane tank | $2.598 per gallon | 0.60 | $47.35 |
| Electric resistance tank | $0.1723 per kWh | 0.95 | $53.15 |
Two results surprise most readers. First, a tankless propane unit beats an electric resistance tank on running cost by a wide margin, because the tankless unit's 0.90 UEF wastes far less of an expensive fuel. Second, propane in a standard tank is nearly as expensive as electric resistance, and both cost roughly three times what a heat pump water heater pays for the same hot water. The conversion factors behind the table: one MMBTU equals 293.07 kWh, 10 therms, or about 10.94 gallons of propane at 91,452 BTU per gallon.
The same load, priced six ways
Take a labeled hypothetical household that uses 50 gallons of hot water a day, heated from 50 degrees F to 120 degrees F. Water weighs 8.33 pounds per gallon and takes one BTU per pound per degree, so the household needs 29,155 BTU of delivered heat a day, or 10.64 MMBTU a year. Run that one load through each option at the prices above:
| Option | Purchased energy per year | Annual running cost | Per month (annual / 12) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Heat pump water heater (UEF 3.50) | 891 kWh | $154 | $13 |
| Gas tankless (condensing, UEF 0.90) | 118 therms | $177 | $15 |
| Natural gas tank (UEF 0.60) | 177 therms | $266 | $22 |
| Propane tankless (condensing, UEF 0.90) | 129 gallons | $336 | $28 |
| Propane tank (UEF 0.60) | 194 gallons | $504 | $42 |
| Electric resistance tank (UEF 0.95) | 3,283 kWh | $566 | $47 |
In monthly terms, then: for this one household an electric resistance tank runs about $47 a month and a heat pump water heater about $13, while a gas tank at the labeled hypothetical $1.50 per therm runs about $22. The gas rows move with your utility rate, so read the gas monthly figure as an example and put your own therm price into the formula above.
So the specific question behind a lot of searches, electricity for a standard tank versus a tankless propane unit, answers like this at these prices: the tankless propane unit runs about $230 a year cheaper than the electric tank, but about $182 a year more than a heat pump water heater, before installation cost, tank rental, or delivery fees. Change the local prices and the gaps move. At 12 cents per kWh, the electric tank drops to about $394 a year. At $3.50 per gallon for propane, the tankless propane unit rises to about $453 a year and the propane tank to about $679. The method below lets you rerun the table with your own bills in about ten minutes.